Skip to Content

Antigua vs Jamaica: Which is the Better Vacation?

Antigua vs Jamaica, Comparing Which is the Better Vacation Between the Two

Choosing between Antigua vs Jamaica? While Jamaica has great nightlife and outdoor activities, Antigua is more laid back and can be cheaper than Jamaica.

Antigua and Jamaica are both alluring Caribbean destinations, but each has its unique allure. While Antigua is known for its 365 breathtaking beaches, one for each day of the year, Jamaica is a vibrant culture-rich island with lush mountains, verdant rainforests, and revered white-sand beaches. Both destinations offer a slice of paradise but cater to different tastes and vacation styles.

Related Travel Guides:


Two of our favorite travel insurance: Heymondo Vs Safetwing cheapest travel Insurance. You can get for $135 USD your Heymondo Travel Insurance with Heymondo discount code valid for 90 days. Read our full comparison of Genki vs Safetywing Travel Insurance Review and the comparison Heymondo vs Genki

Comparing Antigua vs Jamaica:


Picture yourself nestled in the heart of the Caribbean with a choice between two island jewels – Antigua and Jamaica. Antigua, one-half of the nation of Antigua and Barbuda, sits gracefully in the middle of the Leeward Islands. It’s a flat playground for explorers, contrasted by Jamaica’s more robust, mountainous terrain as the third-largest island in the Caribbean.

While Antigua basks in its coral-fringed glory, Jamaica sits south of Cuba and west of Hispaniola, offering a myriad of natural backdrops for every adventurer.


Both islands serve up tropical climates on a sun-soaked platter but with slight variations. Antigua is your haven for a dry, comfortable climate with low humidity year-round, making it a bliss for beach loungers. Meanwhile, Jamaica invites you with a more humid embrace, especially along its picturesque coastal areas, adding a different flavor to the tropical allure.

Attractions – Antigua vs Jamaica

Antigua flaunts its pristine beaches, legendary sailing escapades, and the historic charm of places like Nelson’s Dockyard. It’s a slice of paradise for those with a penchant for sun, sand, and sea, with a touch of history. Jamaica, on the other hand, is a rhythm-infused island famous for its reggae music heritage, Rastafarian culture, and natural attractions like Dunn’s River Falls and the Blue Mountains. It’s a place where your heart beats in sync with the rhythmic tunes of reggae and your soul gets lost in the natural wonders sprinkled across the island.

Culture – Antigua vs Jamaica

Antigua wears its British and African heritage proudly, showcased in its cuisine, music, and vibrant festivals. It’s a place where traditions are celebrated with gusto. On the flip side, Jamaica presents a cultural cocktail with influences from Africa, Britain, Spain, and India, creating a unique blend that’s distinctly Jamaican. It’s a colorful, diverse, and lively cultural concoction that makes Jamaica not just a destination, but an experience. So, whether it’s the old-world charm of Antigua or the rhythm-driven spirit of Jamaica, both islands offer a rich, unforgettable cultural sojourn.

Cost Considerations – Antigua vs Jamaica:

In comparing the travel budgets for a one-week stay in Antigua and Jamaica, several factors come into play such as accommodation, food, transportation, and activities. Here’s a breakdown based on the gathered information with the conversion to USD for better understanding:

One Week Travel Budget in Antigua:

  1. Accommodation: The average hotel room price in Antigua and Barbuda is around $344​
  2. Transportation: Transportation costs could vary widely depending on whether you rent a car, use taxis, or use public buses. For example, car rentals cost about $40-$50 per day, with an additional $20 for a three-month driving permit​
  3. Activities: Various activities like zip-lining, snorkeling, and horseback riding typically range from $20 to $50 per person​
  4. Overall: A week in Antigua can cost anywhere from $250 to $500 depending on activity and dining preferences, excluding the cost of accommodation​.

    For example, a vacation to Saint John’s, Antigua for one week costs around EC$4,205 for one person or EC$8,411 for two people, which converts to approximately $1,556 for one person or $3,112 for two people using an exchange rate of 1 XCD = 0.369672 USD​​

One Week Travel Budget in Jamaica:

  1. Accommodation: For a comfortable stay, the average accommodation cost is mentioned as $275 per night​
  2. Transportation: Transportation costs are roughly estimated at $40 per day​
  3. Food, Drink & Activities: An estimated $100 per person, per day is suggested for food, drink, and activities​
  4. Overall: A vacation to Jamaica for one week usually costs around J$139,907 for one person or J$279,813 for two people, which converts to approximately $1,778 for one person or $3,555 for two people using an exchange rate of 1 JMD = 0.0127 USD (based on an estimated conversion rate as the exact rate was not provided).

    You can also budget J$284,847.19 (around $1,830.02) for one person for a week, with a budget option for two people costing J$274,844.95 (around $1,765.76)​

In conclusion, both destinations can be tailored to fit budget or luxury travel preferences. However, Jamaica appears to have a higher average cost for a one-week vacation compared to Antigua, mainly due to accommodation and daily expenses for food, drinks, and activities. It’s important to note that actual expenses can vary widely based on personal preferences, the choice of accommodation, dining preferences, and the level of activities one engages in during the visit.

Getting There – Antigua vs Jamaica:

Both islands are well served by international airports – V.C. Bird International Airport in Antigua and Sangster International Airport and Norman Manley International Airport in Jamaica.

Getting to Antigua

Jetting off to Antigua is straightforward with several airlines offering direct flights to V.C. Bird International Airport, the gateway to this island paradise.

From the US, direct flights are available from cities like Miami, New York, or Atlanta, whisking you away to the Antiguan shores in no time.

For those with a penchant for maritime adventure, yachts and other sea vessels are welcome to dock at the many marinas scattered around the island.

And once you’re on the island, getting around is easy—catch a local bus or rent a car to explore at your leisure.

Getting to Jamaica

Jamaica is well within reach with its three international airports — Norman Manley International Airport in Kingston, Sangster International Airport in Montego Bay, and Ian Fleming International Airport in Ocho Rios — welcoming travelers from across the globe.

Numerous airlines operate flights to Jamaica from various international destinations, making it simple to find a flight that aligns with your schedule.

If arriving by sea appeals to you, Jamaica’s north coast is a favored stop for many of the world’s renowned cruise lines, including Royal Caribbean and Carnival, with ports in Ocho Rios, Montego Bay, and Falmouth being the most frequented.

Entry into Jamaica requires a valid passport, with no tourist visa needed for stays up to 90 days, although confirmation of your return journey is necessary.

Once you’ve landed, a range of transport options are at your disposal — rent a car or hop on a local bus to delve into the heart and soul of Jamaica.

Whether by air or by sea, both Antigua and Jamaica offer robust connectivity, ready to usher you into their warm, tropical embrace.

Top Things to Do in Antigua

1. Beach-Hopping

Beach Hopping in Antigua - Antigua vs Jamaica
Beach Hopping in Antigua – Antigua vs Jamaica

With 365 beaches, there’s a stretch of sand for every day of the year in Antigua. Start your beach-hopping adventure at Dickenson Bay and make your way around to Half Moon Bay. Each beach has its unique charm, so whether you’re into watersports, lounging with a cocktail, or simply soaking up the sun, there’s a beach for you.

2. Sail the Caribbean Seas

Sailing in Antigua (Antigua vs Jamaica)

Antigua is a sailing haven. The annual Antigua Sailing Week is a testament to its nautical heritage. Charter a yacht or hop aboard a catamaran cruise to explore the island’s coastline, and don’t forget to enjoy a sunset sail – the views are breathtaking!

3. Step Back in Time at Nelson’s Dockyard

Nelson's Dockyard - Antigua vs Jamaica

A visit to Nelson’s Dockyard is like a voyage back to the colonial era. As the world’s only continuously working Georgian dockyard, it’s home to an array of historic buildings and a maritime museum that tells tales of the island’s naval history.

4. Hike to Shirley Heights

Shirley Heights in Antigua - Antigua vs Jamaica

For a panoramic view of Antigua, a hike to Shirley Heights is a must. Once at the top, you’ll be rewarded with stunning vistas of the island and neighboring Guadeloupe. Don’t miss the Sunday barbecue party, a weekly event with live music and dancing as the sun sets.

5. Dive into Underwater Exploration

Pillars of Hercules - Antigua vs Jamaica

Antigua’s clear waters are a playground for divers. Dive sites like the Pillars of Hercules offer a glimpse into the underwater world, with colorful corals and an array of marine life waiting to be discovered.

Top Things to Do in Jamaica

1. Chase Waterfalls

Dunns Waterfalls Jamaica Antigua vs Jamaica

Jamaica’s lush landscape is dotted with stunning waterfalls. Don’t miss a chance to climb the famous Dunn’s River Falls, and explore other hidden gems like Reach Falls and YS Falls for a refreshing dip in nature’s pools.

2. Jam to Reggae Beats

The island pulses with the rhythm of reggae. Visit the Bob Marley Museum in Kingston for a dose of reggae history, and catch live music sessions at local bars and venues across the island to experience the infectious Jamaican musical vibe.

3. Venture into the Blue Mountains

Blue Mountains in Jamaica Antigua vs Jamaica

A journey into the Blue Mountains is a feast for the senses. The cool mountain air, lush greenery, and the aroma of coffee beans from the local coffee plantations are a refreshing change from the beach scene.

4. Get an Adrenaline Rush on the Great River

Blue Hole Jamaica Antigua vs Jamaica

Whether it’s white-water rafting, tubing, or kayaking, the Great River offers a thrill for adventure seekers. Navigate the rapids and enjoy the serene moments in between as you float through the tropical scenery.

5. Explore the Rastafarian Culture

Jamaican Patty in Jamaica Antigua vs Jamaica

Immerse yourself in Jamaica’s Rastafarian culture by visiting a Rasta village, learning about their beliefs, and way of life, and trying some Ital food (a natural, vegetarian diet followed by Rastafarians).

Both Antigua and Jamaica are laden with adventures and cultural experiences that will fill your days with unforgettable memories. Whether you’re a history buff, a nature lover, or someone in search of the ultimate beach getaway, these Caribbean gems have something for everyone.

Accommodations – Antigua vs Jamaica:

Both Antigua and Jamaica offer a delightful mix of accommodations to suit all types of travelers. Whether you’re on a lavish spree or a budget-friendly adventure, these Caribbean gems have something for everyone.

Antigua Accommodations

Luxury Accommodations in Antigua and Barbuda

In Antigua, luxury knows no bounds. Resorts like Carlisle Bay and Jumby Bay Island provide a haven of tranquility with their serene beachfront locations, indulgent spa services, and gourmet dining experiences​. They offer spacious suites and villas, with private pools and breathtaking ocean views, setting the scene for a dreamy island escape.

⭐️ Check the updated prices and book accommodations with the best deals here:

Mid Range Budget Accommodations in Antigua and Barbuda

If your budget is mid-range, worry not! Hotels like Ocean Point Resort & Spa and Siboney Beach Club have got you covered. They offer cozy accommodations with modern amenities, ensuring a comfortable stay without burning a hole in your pocket​.

⭐️ Check the updated prices and book accommodations with the best deals here:

Low Budget Accommodations Accommodations in Antigua and Barbuda

For the budget-conscious traveler, places like the Eko Cozy Guesthouse offer a homely ambiance with basic amenities at an affordable price. It’s a great way to experience local hospitality without breaking the bank​.

Accommodations in Jamaica

Luxury Accommodations in Jamaica

Jamaica is synonymous with all-inclusive luxury. Resorts like Sandals, Beaches, and others listed among the top all-inclusive resorts by TripAdvisor, offer an opulent array of amenities including gourmet eateries, private pools, and luxury spas​. They ensure a hassle-free vacation where every desire is just a request away.

⭐️ Check the updated prices and book accommodations with the best deals here:

Mid-Budget Accommodations in Jamaica

If luxury isn’t your calling, plenty of mid-range hotels like the Jamaica Inn in Ocho Rios provide a slice of paradise without the hefty price tag. With its white sand beach and luxe amenities, it’s a perfect retreat for sun-seekers and beach bums​

⭐️ Check updated prices (with the best deals) for Jamaica Inn

Low Budget ($65-85 USD/night) Accommodations in Jamaica

On the budget end, Jamaica has a variety of guesthouses and budget hotels that provide a comfortable stay without costing an arm and a leg. They are perfect for travelers looking to explore the culture and beauty of Jamaica on a budget.

⭐️ Check the highest-rated and low-budget accommodations for Jamaica below:

In summary, whether you’re looking for opulent resorts, comfy mid-range hotels, or budget-friendly guesthouses, both Antigua and Jamaica have a plethora of options to choose from. The choice really depends on your personal preferences and budget.

Getting Around – Antigua vs Jamaica:

In both islands, renting a car, hiring a taxi, or using local buses are common ways to get around. However, Jamaica has a larger land area with more extensive public transportation options.

When comparing the ease of getting around in Antigua and Jamaica, there are several factors to consider including the availability and convenience of public transportation, car rentals, and the quality of the roads.

Getting Around in Antigua

In Antigua, getting around is relatively straightforward with various options available:

  1. Car Rentals: Car rental services are readily available and cater to visitors conveniently, especially at the V.C. Bird International Airport. Budget Rent-A-Car is one of the car rental services that provide convenient and affordable rental options​
  2. Taxis: Taxis are easily accessible, especially from the airport and major hotels. The fare from the airport to St. John’s is around $7, but it increases to around $31 and up to English Harbour​
  3. Public Buses: There’s a small bus network in Antigua, particularly within St. John’s. Buses are a much cheaper alternative to taxis, although they can be unpredictable with no set schedule, making the journey between St. John’s and smaller villages somewhat bumpy​
  4. Driving: Road conditions in Antigua are decent on the main roads, but may become dirt tracks off the beaten path. Many rental agencies can assist with obtaining an Antiguan driving permit, which costs around $20 for three months​

Getting Around in Jamaica

On the other hand, Jamaica also offers multiple options for getting around:

  1. Public Transportation: In Kingston, large air-conditioned luxury coaches run regularly on popular routes. Outside the capital, the public transport services are less regular with islanders mainly using buses, minibuses, and route taxis​
  2. Driving: According to Lonely Planet, driving is considered the best way to get around in Jamaica. The roads are well-connected and easily navigated by car, making it a convenient option for visiting the island’s best places​
  3. Privately Run Minibuses and Route Taxis: There’s a comprehensive, albeit chaotic, network of privately run minibuses. Shared route taxis are great for short distances and are a cheap way to travel​
  4. Taxis and Buses: Independent travelers in Jamaica have the option to use taxis and buses to get around, which is considered a cheap way to explore the island, especially for those looking to experience the local life​

In summary, both Antigua and Jamaica have a range of transportation options. While Antigua has a structured yet limited public transportation system, car rental and taxis seem to be more convenient for visitors. Jamaica, on the other hand, has a more robust public transportation system alongside car rental and taxi options, offering a bit more flexibility in terms of getting around.

Currency and Money – Antigua vs Jamaica

Navigating through the monetary landscape of a foreign land is a crucial aspect of any travel endeavor. In the Caribbean jewels of Antigua and Jamaica, the financial frameworks are distinct yet accommodating. Here’s a delve into their currency and money management aspects:


  • Antigua: The official currency of Antigua and Barbuda is the Eastern Caribbean Dollar (XCD), which maintains a stable exchange rate, ensuring consistency for travelers when converting their home currencies.
  • Jamaica: On the other hand, Jamaica operates with the Jamaican Dollar (JMD), whose exchange rate may fluctuate, thus requiring travelers to stay updated on current rates.

Credit Card Acceptance:

  • Both islands exhibit a modern financial infrastructure where credit cards are widely accepted. Major credit cards like Visa, MasterCard, and American Express find acceptance in most hotels, restaurants, and tourist establishments, providing a seamless transaction experience for visitors.

ATM Availability:

  • Antigua: ATMs are readily available, particularly in urban areas and tourist hotspots, making cash access relatively hassle-free.
  • Jamaica: Similarly, Jamaica boasts a good number of ATMs in urban centers and tourist areas, allowing easy access to cash when needed.

Currency Exchange:

  • In both Antigua and Jamaica, currency exchange facilities are readily available at airports, banks, and hotels, ensuring visitors can conveniently exchange their currency.

Cash vs Card:

  • While credit cards provide a layer of convenience, carrying some cash is advisable for small purchases, transportation fares, or visiting local markets where card facilities might not be available.


  • Tipping practices in both islands are similar, with a general guideline of tipping 10-15% in restaurants and other service establishments, provided a service charge hasn’t been added to the bill.

In summary, both Antigua and Jamaica provide a tourist-friendly monetary environment. The stable exchange rate of the Eastern Caribbean Dollar in Antigua might offer a slight edge in financial predictability over the fluctuating rates of the Jamaican Dollar. Nonetheless, the widespread acceptance of credit cards and the availability of ATMs ensure that managing finances while exploring the vibrant cultures and picturesque landscapes of either island remains a smooth sail.

Best Time to Visit – Antigua vs Jamaica

The best time to visit Antigua and Jamaica varies depending on your preferences for weather, crowd sizes, and prices. Here’s a comparison based on the gathered information:

Best Time to Visit Antigua:

  1. Dry Season (December – April):
    • The dry season from December to April is considered the best time to visit Antigua, offering pleasant weather with little to no chance of rain showers, and plenty of sunshine​
    • This period is also the peak tourist season, especially from mid-December to mid-April, providing an escape from wintery conditions in the US or Europe​
  2. Wet Season (May – November):
    • The wettest months are from September to November, but prices are more attractive during this time, and temperatures remain warm​
    • The official hurricane season runs from July to November, though the risk is considered low​

Best Time to Visit Jamaica

  1. Dry Season (November – April):
    • The best time to visit Jamaica is from November to mid-December when the island experiences its most pleasant weather with temperatures ranging from the mid-70s to the high 80s Fahrenheit​
    • Most travelers visit Jamaica in the winter, specifically from December to March, aligning with the country’s high season. This is when services are in full swing, beaches are bustling, and prices are at their highest​
  2. Wet Season (May – October):
    • From June through November, the temperatures rise with daily highs reaching around 91°F, marking the low tourist season. This period offers a quieter and cheaper vacation option, albeit with a higher chance of rain and storms​

In summary, if you prefer dry and sunny weather, visiting either Antigua or Jamaica from December to April would be ideal. For budget-conscious travelers, the wet season in both destinations offers lower prices and fewer crowds, though with a higher likelihood of encountering rain and storms.

Our Conclusions and Final Thoughts on Antigua vs Jamaica

Your choice between Antigua and Jamaica may come down to personal preferences. For a laid-back beach or sailing vacation, Antigua might be the better choice. However, if you’re looking for a vibrant culture, music, and a variety of natural attractions, Jamaica could be the more appealing destination.

Through a thorough examination of various travel aspects, we journeyed through the vibrant experiences these islands offer, from their picturesque beaches to their rich culinary traditions. Let’s revisit our exploration:

  1. Things to Do:
    • Antigua: Known for its 365 beaches, one for each day of the year, Antigua is a haven for beach lovers. The island also offers a range of water sports, historical tours, and nature explorations.
    • Jamaica: With its reggae beats, Jamaica presents a lively atmosphere alongside beautiful beaches, waterfalls, and historical sites like the Bob Marley Museum.
  2. Budget:
    • Antigua: Generally, a more budget-friendly option with a range of accommodations and activities to fit varying financial preferences.
    • Jamaica: Tends to be pricier, especially during the peak season, yet offers a wide variety of experiences worth the expense.
  3. Accommodations:
    • Antigua: Provides a spectrum of stay options from luxury resorts to budget-friendly hotels.
    • Jamaica: Boasts an array of accommodations catering to different tastes, including all-inclusive resorts and quaint beachfront cottages.
  4. Culture and Food:
    • Antigua: Delivers a calm and serene atmosphere with a touch of historical charm, complemented by its unique Antiguan cuisine.
    • Jamaica: A vibrant culture reflected in its music, dance, and spicy, flavorful foods like jerk chicken.
  5. Experiences:
    • Antigua: Ideal for a relaxed and laid-back holiday with a blend of beach activities and historical tours.
    • Jamaica: Offers a lively holiday experience with bustling nightlife, music festivals, and adventurous outdoor activities.
  6. Best Time to Visit:
    • Both islands share a similar climate pattern with the dry season (December to April) being the ideal time to visit for pleasant weather, while the wet season (May to November) offers a more budget-friendly travel option.

Hope we were able to give you a great look at the experiences you can get in both Antigua and Jamaica to help you make the best decision. Have questions? Feel free to drop them in the comments below.

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Please note that we only recommend products and services that we have personally used or believe will add value to our readers. Your support through these links helps us to continue creating informative and engaging content. Thank you for your support!